Recycling your electronic waste is a noble idea, but here’s the dirty little secret: even if you drop off your old electronics for recycling, it may never get recycled.
As OSNews’ Howard Fosdick describes some people fall victim to a scam called “fake recycling,” and just describing it leaves a bitter taste in my mouth.
Fake recyclers are organizations that approach well-meaning community groups like the Boy Scouts or the Make-a-Wish Foundation to help run a local “Recycling Day.” The idea is that people from the community will bring in their old electronics to the legitimate organization’s Recycling Day event. The fake recycler will then haul that e-waste away, and export it to another country with lax environmental regulations.
What’s in it for them? According to the Electronics TakeBack Coalition, “Recyclers can make more money by exporting than they can by actually responsibly recycling. This is particularly true for recyclers who are collecting televisions, because it costs money to properly recycle old televisions. But they can get paid for exporting them.”
This story from the Basel Action Network details how Cartoosa, OK-based company, EarthEcycle allegedly conned the Humane Society and several other groups into running a “Recycle Day” Event, and then exported the goods to Hong Kong and South Africa. Last year, the EPA filed charges against the company for violating at least seven federal hazardous waste management regulation.
The EPA found other companies located in the state of Washington and Texas as well as in New Jersey illegally disposing of electronic waste.
Most people have never heard of a fake recycling organization like EarthEcycle, but plenty of people know all about the Boy Scouts or the Make-a-Wish Foundation. And that’s exactly why fake recycler organizations need the help of legitimate groups, which lend the good name and publicity to the event.
The crazy thing is that none of this is illegal, but it’s definitely destroying the environment. Here are a few tips from Electronics Takeback Coalition to keep a lookout for fake recyclers to make sure that you (or a group you represent) don’t get scammed.
First off, remember that responsibly recycling an item is not free, especially when it comes to electronics. If it’s not you forking over the cash to recycle an old computer, find out who is. Some electronics companies now take your old electronics back when you buy a new one, as are some state and local governments.
If you really want to do right by the environment, seek out an e-waste recycler on your own. You can find plenty of them on e-Stewards. There are also eclectic groups like FreeGeek Chicago that refurbish your old computers for people who can’t afford their own.
Both of those options sound a lot better than letting your old computer sink into a landfill.
Source

July 11th, 2010 at 14:56
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Casilda Mancini and others. Casilda Mancini said: Fake Recyclers Profit Off E-Waste: Recycling your electronic waste is a noble idea, but here's the dirty little se… http://bit.ly/dx6C5M [...]
October 28th, 2010 at 22:30
Why isn't recycling for free? Any intelligent person knows each of the components in "ewaste" have value. Even BANs estewards sell thier stuff for profit and get paid up front for "disposal" or "processing". Plastics sell for $0.05/lb, copper is up to over $3.55/lb gold, silver and glass are even sold. The onl;y main issue is the lead which can't be re-used and must end up n land fills. BAn is not fooling anyone, the bad press is the one dupping the public. At least EarthEcycle is giving money to charities. Keep using scary words to fools the public…your words are volitile and corrupt and your alligations are lies.
May 21st, 2012 at 09:00
The fake recyclers who promise of a dedicated work are actually earning more but ‘tossing’ to others what they are supposed to be working on. Will this be a continuous cycle? We hope not.